A Cost Comparison: Fractional Leaders vs. Full-Time Execs (Natalie Stones)

Most organizations understand the value of having a leader in an executive role to guide their business, but it's not always financially feasible, there may not always be a full time need, or some struggle to find the right person. As a result, fractional leadership has become increasingly popular as an alternative means to leveraging executive level talent. 

As a reminder from our last post, the benefits of hiring a fractional are the flexibility it offers in terms of time commitment and the ability to access talented leaders at a fraction of the cost. Additionally, working with fractionals does not require businesses to make significant investments in infrastructure or resources—the professional provides all necessary tools and resources themselves.

Since this is an emerging and growing concept, I was eager to explore the cost of a FTE (full-time employee) compensation plan, in comparisons to fractional monthly retainers. The data is eye opening to say the least!

According to data gathered (March 2023) by Salary.com, the median (50th percentile) core compensation (salary+benefits*) for the following C-Suite leaders is as follows:

  • Chief Financial Officer (CFO)- $558,999 ($46,583/mo) + 22% bonus

  • Chief Operating Officer (COO)- $622,672 ($51,889/mo) + 23% bonus

  • Chief Marketing Officer (CMO)- $464,651 ($38,720/mo) + 25% bonus

  • Chief Revenue Officer (CRO)- $408,619 ($34,051/mo) + 12% bonus

  • Chief Technology Officer (CTO)- $387,001 ($32,250/mo) + 15% bonus

  • Chief Human Resources Officer (CHRO)- $449,340 ($37,445/mo) + 25% bonus

  • NEWER-Chief Talent Officer (CTAO)- $337,197 ($28,099/mo) + 20% bonus

*For the full cost breakdowns, including salary + benefits + bonus, click each roles hyperlink. Bonus comp and equity cash totals were left out of this comparison, since both are variable compensation, not always guaranteed. Average % offered were noted instead.

What is the average monthly retainer for a fractional executive?

The average monthly retainer for fractional executives starts at around $5,000 and goes upwards to $15,000 per month. Retainers vary depending on the experience, scope of work, and level of hourly commitment per month (ie. 25%, 50%, or 75% commitment to the team/company). The retainer may be higher if the professional has more years of experience, is in high demand, or if the organization is located in a major metropolitan area.

What is the arrangement?

Fractional executives typically invest 40-60 hours per month with each client that they provide services for. This time commitment is tailored to the specific needs of the client, allowing for more or less time as needed. Factional executives spend their weeks working directly with each client as part of the team, while also taking care of behind the scenes tasks, like building operational efficiencies, strategic planning, creating presentations, managing projects, doing research and analysis, and handling communications. Depending on the complexity of the project at hand, they may spend additional time refining their plans and strategies in order to optimize results.

Overall, businesses that need executive level expertise but lack the resources or willingness to hire full-time employees often benefit from fractional leadership solutions as they provide access to experienced professionals at significantly reduced rates while still offering customizable solutions tailored specifically towards client needs.

Comments

  1. Joan Varrone- Fractional CFOMarch 27, 2023 at 8:40 PM

    Fractional executives are a very cost -effective solution as this post points out. I have been in a fractional CFO role for over a decade (when I started there was not a fractional title and the word consultant was the nomenclature). This role is particularly beneficial to early- stage companies but full- time executives at start- ups do not earn the level of compensation referenced by Salary.com and are granted stock options which could produce a large upside. However, there is still a very compelling cost advantage as well and the skill set needed at an early stage start up is someone who is more hands-on as there is no staff at this stage. The time dedicated each month by the fractional CXO will depend on the stage of the company and will grow over time until there is a point where it makes sense to engage a full time executive. The fractional CXO will have established a strong foundation so that the full time CXO will be able to take hit the ground running and take the company to the next level. The presence of a competent fractional CXO also allows the company to take the time to find the right full-time leader.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Mimi CorrellJuly 23, 2024 at 7:51 PM

    thank you for distinguishing the 2 lanes!
    https://metaexperts.com/fractional-executives/

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Fractional vs Consultant (Karina Mikhli)

Image
Now that "fractional" is more popular and in the news, it is important to understand what the difference between that and consulting is. I was recently part of an Operator's Guild panel on just this topic, and as part of our presentation deck, created the below table to highlight the differences between all the types of non-traditional leadership roles: To put it simply, there is no difference between a fractional CXO and their full-time counterpart except that the fractional will be part-time and therefore have other work, whether other fractional or consulting work. I personally do a combination of fractional COO work and workflow consulting. And fractional is always a leadership role, although not necessarily executive level, and needs to be synonymous with that.  Another way to look at the difference between fractionals and consultants is through two more lenses: what are they hired for and what their focus has to be. Consultants are hired for their skills; they may ...
Read more

1.2% Wake-Up Call: Resourceful Employers Respond to Rising Labor Costs (Bonni Kaplan DeWoskin)

The numbers are in, and they're telling a story every employer needs to hear. Last quarter, the Employment Cost Index (ECI) rose by 1.2%, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, putting pressure on businesses across industries. From the corner office to customer service desks, companies are feeling the squeeze of rising labor costs. But here's the thing: this challenge is also an opportunity. Resourceful employers should recognize that surviving in such environments is about investing, not cutting. What does that mean? It means investing in strategies that will drive long-term growth and success, instead of just cutting costs for short-term gain. One strategy that is gaining traction quickly is fractional leadership. Imagine being able to tap into the expertise of a seasoned C-suite executive, but on a flexible, part-time basis that aligns with your budget and needs. That's the power of fractional leadership—a terrific solution for companies looking to adapt without sa...
Read more

Optimizing and Moving Forward: A Farewell (For Now) to the Fractionals United Blog

When I launched Fractionals United 17 months ago, having a blog to share opinions and content, which could then be reposted, was a well-established practice. To make it more sustainable and diverse, I decided to make it community-sourced rather than purely about my own thoughts. Now, after 17 months and 69 posts, I believe the blog has served its purpose. We have developed other channels for sharing and content, so as our communication strategies evolve, so must our approach. Those who know me well (and those who have heard John Arms speak of this) are aware that I wear a bracelet with the word "optimize" engraved on it. This serves not only as a reflection of my personal philosophy but also as a constant reminder that there is always room for improvement. What is valuable today may not be as valuable tomorrow. The optimal approach to any task today may require adjustments in the future as variables change and priorities shift. Recognizing this, it is time for FrUn to further...
Read more